The Cost of a Bad Leadership Hire in the UK, and How to Avoid One
Everyone agrees a bad senior hire is expensive. Fewer people have put a number on it, and the number changes how much time and money a sensible business spends on the search.
The figures
REC: a poor hire at manager level costs UK businesses an average of £132,000 once productivity loss, management time and team impact are counted
SHRM: replacing an employee costs 50 to 200% of annual salary. At the top of that range, a £180,000 CFO who leaves at month nine has cost the business up to £360,000 before you count the second search
CIPD: 41% of UK employers made a poor hiring decision they later regretted in the previous 12 months
Industry estimate: 10 to 25% of hires do not work out inside the first year
At leadership level the direct costs are the smaller part. The larger part is the decisions not taken, the people who leave because of the hire, and the twelve months the business spends standing still.
Why leadership hires fail
The brief described the job, not the business. Skills matched, culture did not
Interviews tested what the candidate had done, not how they behave when the plan changes
The hiring panel was not aligned on what good looked like, so the loudest voice chose
Nobody checked how the candidate had actually left their last two roles
The first 90 days had no structure, and the new leader was judged on impressions formed in week two
The one change that prevents most of it
Reverse the order of assessment. Most hiring processes check skill first, then attitude, then culture if there is time. Do it the other way round: write down the culture before the search starts, interview for attitude and behaviour under pressure, and only then verify the technical skill. Skill is the easiest of the three to assess and the least likely to be the reason someone fails.
Three things to do on your next senior hire
Write a one-page culture map before the role goes to market, and give it to every candidate
Use the same structured interview for every shortlisted candidate, scored, with the panel aligned on the scoring before the first interview
Book a 90-day check-in with the new leader and their manager into the diary on day one
This is the method we run on every search. It is written down in full on how we hire. If you have a brief and want a view on whether it needs retained or permanent search, how we work with you explains both.
Comments